Shoshana

Shoshana

25/7/2025 2h 1m 6.5/10

Overview

In this edge-of-your-seat thriller inspired by real events, a British police officer and a Jewish woman fall in love amidst the political turmoil of 1930s Tel Aviv. With British control over Palestine precarious and conflict inevitable, everyone is forced to choose a side.

Director

Michael Winterbottom

Top Billed Cast

Harry Melling

Harry Melling

Geoffrey Morton

Irina Starshenbaum

Irina Starshenbaum

Shoshana Borochov

Douglas Booth

Douglas Booth

Thomas Wilkin

Liudmyla Vasylieva

Luba Borochov

Gina Bramhill

Gina Bramhill

Alice Morton

Aury Alby

Avraham Stern

Reviews

CinemaSerf

CinemaSerf

3/6/2024

6/10

This is a curiously undercooked iteration of a story that well exemplifies that expression about one man's terrorist being another's freedom fighter. It's the underwhelming Douglas Booth who is Wilkin, a police detective based in British-administered Palestine and a man who has a semblance of decency to him. His boss "Chambers" (Ian Hart) is a bit more of a player, though - and he drafts in the much more "hands-on" Morton (the unremarkable Harry Melling) to get results more quickly - not least the apprehension of Stern (Aury Alby) who is determined to establish a Jewish homeland and doesn't much care which tactics he uses to accomplish that. The personal story is largely historical fact, so there's no real jeopardy here, but it's an interesting postulation on just how the British tried to administer a region and a population that had no interest in being administered, and that was being logistically manipulated with the shortest of term vision for anyone's future. Palestinian and Jew could agree on just one thing - get the UK out, but thereafter there was little consensus as the bombs and the bullets continued to fly. To be honest, I found the contribution of the eponymous woman (Irina Starshenbaum) to be almost incidental to what is essentially a rather dryly brutal story of a territory that always has been and will be fought over. It looks fine, but somehow it's all just a little too bitty - episodic, even, and it needed a bigger hitter to deliver the narrative more engagingly and convincingly. Pity.

Similar Movies

Saving Private Ryan

8.2

Saving Private Ryan

1998

Black Hawk Down

7.4

Black Hawk Down

2001

The Lives of Others

8.0

The Lives of Others

2006

Enemy at the Gates

7.4

Enemy at the Gates

2001

Memoirs of a Geisha

7.6

Memoirs of a Geisha

2005

All the President's Men

7.7

All the President's Men

1976

Cinderella Man

7.6

Cinderella Man

2005

World Trade Center

6.1

World Trade Center

2006

The Killing Fields

7.5

The Killing Fields

1984

The Legend of Boggy Creek

5.0

The Legend of Boggy Creek

1972

Anwar: The Untold Story

5.5

Anwar: The Untold Story

2023

Mannen utan ansikte

6.0

Mannen utan ansikte

1995