The Proposition

The Proposition

9/6/2006 1h 44m 7.0/10

Overview

In 1880s Australia, a lawman offers renegade Charlie Burns a difficult choice. In order to save his younger brother from the gallows, Charlie must hunt down and kill his older brother, who is wanted for rape and murder. Venturing into one of the Outback's most inhospitable regions, Charlie faces a terrible moral dilemma that can end only in violence.

Director

John Hillcoat

Top Billed Cast

Danny Huston

Danny Huston

Arthur Burns

Guy Pearce

Guy Pearce

Charlie Burns

Emily Watson

Emily Watson

Martha Stanley

David Wenham

David Wenham

Eden Fletcher

Ray Winstone

Ray Winstone

Captain Morris Stanley

Richard Wilson

Richard Wilson

Mike Burns

Reviews

Wuchak

4/6/2025

7/10

**_Heart of Darkness in Australia_** Captain Stanley (Ray Winstone) is the new lawman of the territory and he's determined to civilize the brutal wasteland. A band of outlaws comprised of three brothers and a few others stand in his way. Yet two of the brothers want out after their sibling leader commits a crime in one of his raids. The two are apprehended by Capt. Stanley, who offers a proposition to the older of the two (Guy Pearce): Find and assassinate the leader and both will go free. "The Proposition" (2005) is a Western that takes place in Australia, yet it's far from a typical Western. The filmmaking, cinematography, actors, locations, soundtrack and editing are top-of-the-line with a surreal, haunting edge. As my title blurb suggests, there are similarities to "Heart of Darkness" and the original "Apocalypse Now," although it fails to achieve the greatness of the latter. The story plays out in a realistic manner with long stretches of drama and bleak landscapes interspersed with flashes of extreme violence. Ray Winstone and Guy Pearce are great as the two main protagonists. Capt. Stanley understandably wants to rid the land of the brute outlaws, whereas Charlie seeks redemption for himself and his little brother. Danny Huston is captivating as the focal point and villain, Arthur Burns. Yet he's not a villain in the cliched sense and he's not one-dimensional. He loves the beauty of God's creation, he loves the art of language and he's a mystic of sorts, but he clearly crossed the line at some point in his outlaw endeavors and now must be wiped off the face of the planet. Will Charlie do it? My only criticism is that the film seems too short at 1 hour, 44 minutes. It needed more time for details and character development. As it is, we sort of have to guess the details, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. I just wish the film would have gone the route of "Apocalypse Now" and given us more definition and development. At the end of the day, this is one of those films that gets better with repeat viewings, as long as you like the approach of films like "Apocalypse Now," just way shorter (too short). I would love to see a Director's Cut that adds about 20-45 minutes. It was shot in Winton, Queensland, which is in the northeast Outback of Australia. GRADE: B+

Similar Movies

The Man from Hell

3.5

The Man from Hell

1977

Little Lord Fauntleroy

6.7

Little Lord Fauntleroy

1936

Christmas Bedtime Stories

5.8

Christmas Bedtime Stories

2022

Seven Men from Now

6.8

Seven Men from Now

1956

The Talk of the Town

7.3

The Talk of the Town

1942

Werckmeister Harmonies

7.9

Werckmeister Harmonies

2001

3:15 the Moment of Truth

5.5

3:15 the Moment of Truth

1986

Sesame Street: Elmo Saves Christmas

5.9

Sesame Street: Elmo Saves Christmas

1996

Punishment Park

7.3

Punishment Park

1971

Love Takes Wing

6.9

Love Takes Wing

2009

King of the Ants

5.9

King of the Ants

2004

A Boyfriend for Christmas

5.6

A Boyfriend for Christmas

2004

Armitage: Dual Matrix

6.4

Armitage: Dual Matrix

2002

Molokai: la isla maldita

4.0

Molokai: la isla maldita

1959

The Greatest Store in the World

4.8

The Greatest Store in the World

1999