They Made Me a Criminal

They Made Me a Criminal

21/1/1939 1h 32m 6.2/10

Overview

A boxer flees, believing he has committed a murder while he was drunk.

Director

Busby Berkeley

Top Billed Cast

Claude Rains

Claude Rains

Det. Monty Phelan

May Robson

May Robson

Grandma Rafferty

John Garfield

John Garfield

Johnnie Bradfield, aka Jack Dorney

Billy Halop

Billy Halop

Tommy

Ann Sheridan

Ann Sheridan

Goldie West

Gloria Dickson

Gloria Dickson

Peggy

Reviews

CinemaSerf

CinemaSerf

6/22/2022

7/10

This is one of these films that you need to allow quite a bit of latitude, else you will rule it just too implausible and stop watching. John Garfield ("Johnnie") is a world champion boxer who finds himself embroiled in the death of a journalist. His problem is, he was totally sozzled after his victory so cannot recall what he did, or didn't, do - so absconds to a remote Arizona ranch where he helps the elderly May Robson who runs a refuge for wayward teenagers. That's where he meets, and falls for "Peggy" (Gloria Dickson) and settles down to a respectable life helping teach the boys how to focus their energies on boxing. Thing is, New York plod "Whelan" (Claude Rains) is on his case, and soon this newly found utopia is at risk... Garfield does a fitting job here, he is eminently plausible as the flawed prizefighter and his character's evolution as the story develops is engaging too. Rains features sparingly for much of the film, and I found his efforts a little disappointingly constrained when he did appear. The film really, for me anyway, belonged to the "Dead End Kids" - playing the best game of strip poker I think I've ever seen in a family movie. It's a bit too long, but has good pace, plenty of action, decent dialogue and the romance is kept to a minimum - well worth a watch.

Similar Movies

Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

7.4

Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

1992

Poodle Springs

5.4

Poodle Springs

1998

Beverly Hills Cop II

6.5

Beverly Hills Cop II

1987

Lady in the Lake

6.0

Lady in the Lake

1946

The Long Goodbye

7.4

The Long Goodbye

1973

Fantomas vs. Scotland Yard

6.7

Fantomas vs. Scotland Yard

1967

Murder, My Sweet

7.3

Murder, My Sweet

1944

Crime of Passion

6.1

Crime of Passion

1956

The Brasher Doubloon

5.9

The Brasher Doubloon

1947