The Woman in Question

The Woman in Question

18/2/1952 1h 28m 6.2/10

Overview

Agnes "Astra" Huston, a fortune teller at a run-down fair, is found strangled in her bedroom. As the police question five suspects, their interactions with her are shown in flashbacks from their point of view.

Director

George Pollock

Top Billed Cast

Dirk Bogarde

Dirk Bogarde

R.W. (Bob) Baker

Hermione Baddeley

Hermione Baddeley

Mrs. Finch

Jean Kent

Jean Kent

Agnes / Madame Astra / Parrot (voice)

John McCallum

John McCallum

Michael Murray

Charles Victor

Charles Victor

Albert Pollard

Susan Shaw

Susan Shaw

Catherine Taylor

Reviews

CinemaSerf

CinemaSerf

12/30/2024

7/10

Rhetorical question but how is it possible to murder a fortune teller? Surely she should have anticipated the crime and had the constabulary ready and waiting? Well apparently not as "Madame Astra" (Jean Kent) is found slain. It falls to policeman "Lodge" (Duncan Macrae) to try and piece together just what might have happened to her. Now it was a fairly tight knit community and this woman wasn't universally liked. She didn't exactly get on with her sister, nor with her intended (Dirk Bogarde) of whom it has to be said is probably a bit of a rake. Meantime, she seems to have taken advantage of local shopkeeper "Pollard" (Charles Victor) as well as seafaring man "Michael" (John McCallum) and all under the nosey gaze of her housekeeper "Mrs. Finch" (Hermione Baddeley). Many of their alibis overlap and it's interesting for the copper to learn a few different permutations of the lead up to events and the one thing that is certain: she was a bit of a manipulatrix who was perfectly prepared to use her wiles to her own advantage. It's nice to see Macrae given a part a little more substantial than his usual professional Scotsman and I did quite enjoy the efforts from Baddeley and the multi-faceted Kent as the mystery gradually comes together. It's one of those whodunits where you feel half way through that the killer probably merited a medal rather than the noose, but that's always assuming they get caught!

Similar Movies

Stir of Echoes

6.7

Stir of Echoes

1999

Miami Supercops

6.4

Miami Supercops

1985

New Police Story

7.2

New Police Story

2004

The Life of David Gale

7.4

The Life of David Gale

2003

What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?

7.9

What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?

1962

Crimes and Misdemeanors

7.4

Crimes and Misdemeanors

1989

The Honeymoon Killers

6.6

The Honeymoon Killers

1970

Thieves and Robbers

6.1

Thieves and Robbers

1983

Hush... Hush, Sweet Charlotte

7.3

Hush... Hush, Sweet Charlotte

1964

Solo for Clarinet

5.7

Solo for Clarinet

1998