The Comancheros

The Comancheros

1/11/1961 1h 45m 6.6/10

Overview

Texas Ranger Jake Cutter arrests gambler Paul Regret, but soon finds himself teamed with his prisoner in an undercover effort to defeat a band of renegade arms merchants and thieves known as Comancheros.

Director

Michael Curtiz

Top Billed Cast

John Wayne

John Wayne

Jake Cutter

Lee Marvin

Lee Marvin

Crow

Michael Ansara

Michael Ansara

Amelung

Nehemiah Persoff

Nehemiah Persoff

Graile

Stuart Whitman

Stuart Whitman

Paul Regret

Ina Balin

Ina Balin

Pilar Graile

Reviews

John Chard

5/9/2014

6.5/10

Just like your first rattler. One look and you'll know. After winning a duel with a prominent and connected New Orleans man, gambler Paul Regret (Stuart Whitman) has to flee on account of impending arrest for murder. But he is soon captured by Texas Ranger, Jake Cutter (John Wayne), who sets about returning him to Louisiana to be hanged. However, in spite of their obvious professional differences, the men are forced to come together to fight The Comancheros, renegade white men who smuggle guns and whiskey to the Comanche Indians. The credentials for The Comancheros are out of the top draw. Directed by Michael Curtiz, starring John Wayne, with support from the likes of Lee Marvin, Henry Daniel, Edgar Buchanan, Ina Balin, Jack Elam & Bruce Cabot. While the score is provided by Elmer Bernstein and cinematography is courtesy of William H. Clothier. It's based on a story by Paul Wellman and although far from being a top tier Duke Wayne Oater, it's an amiable action packed movie that has an old fashioned feel to it. This was to be Curtiz's last film as he was to pass away shortly afterwards, he was helped on the direction by Wayne who requested to be uncredited for his work, while Cliff Lyons was on hand for some of the action sequences. The acting is solid and the cast seem to be having fun, though a romantic strand between Whitman's Regret & Balin's Pilar is badly developed, but around them all is the Utah & Arizona locale which is beautifully utilised by the talented Clothier. An entertaining Oater to pass away a Sunday afternoon with. 6/10

drystyx

4/18/2023

9/10

A Western Divine Comedy. This Duke Western is a modern day Dante's Inferno, as two protagonists enter a Hell on Earth. This "Hell" is created by an evil sadist played by Nehemiah Persoff. The two protagonists are Jake, played by John Wayne, and Regret, played by Stuart Whitman. Jake is a no nonsense Texas ranger with a weakness. He's honest. Regret is a likable lady's man who never looks for trouble, but trouble always finds him. Ina Balin plays the love interest for Regret. She becomes the "guide" into Hell late into the film. She has two helpers, played by Michael Ansara and Richard Devon. At the time this was made, Ansara was playing honorable characters and Devon less honorable characters, so a "switch" was made on their roles in this film. Ansara plays a sadist even worse than Persoff's devil. Lee Marvin gets a high billing, but has a role that would normally be about 12th billing. The wit and charm of this Western really makes it a semi classic. It has the greatest of the famous Duke lines: "Don't make a habit of saying that too often, and once more will be too often". That lines sticks out among the great lines of his films as the coolest. The protagonists begin with Jake arresting Regret, but Jake has to take Regret through an outskirt of Hell, and Regret finds an opportunity to escape. Later, he accidentally finds Regret while working undercover to investigate Crow, played by Lee Marvin. The "Divine Comedy" of the West sees different supporting characters in this man made Hell, and how they react. There's McBain, Crow, Esteban, Gordo, and others. Who will reject Hell and who will fight to keep Hell intact?

Similar Movies

The Living Daylights

6.5

The Living Daylights

1987

Lone Wolf McQuade

6.5

Lone Wolf McQuade

1983

McCabe & Mrs. Miller

7.2

McCabe & Mrs. Miller

1971

Across the Great Divide

6.1

Across the Great Divide

1976

The Lawless Legion

0.0

The Lawless Legion

1929

Serena and the Ratts

5.0

Serena and the Ratts

2012

All Through the Night

6.9

All Through the Night

1942

Fighting Valley

0.0

Fighting Valley

1943

The Outcasts of Poker Flat

5.9

The Outcasts of Poker Flat

1952

Three in the Saddle

0.0

Three in the Saddle

1945

Bob le Flambeur

7.3

Bob le Flambeur

1956

The Lone Star Vigilantes

0.0

The Lone Star Vigilantes

1942

Hail to the Rangers

0.0

Hail to the Rangers

1943

Three Guns for Texas

5.0

Three Guns for Texas

1968