The Hanging Tree

The Hanging Tree

11/2/1959 1h 47m 6.7/10

Overview

Joseph "Doc" Frail is a doctor with a past he's trying to outrun. While in Montana, he comes across a mining camp with a hanging tree and rescues a man named Rune from the noose. With Rune as his servant, Frail decides to settle down, and he takes over as town doctor. He meets Elizabeth, who is suffering from shock, and the two soon fall in love. But when Elizabeth is attacked, Frail's attempt to help her lands them both in trouble.

Director

Delmer Daves

Top Billed Cast

Virginia Gregg

Virginia Gregg

Edna Flaunce

George C. Scott

George C. Scott

George Grubb

Gary Cooper

Gary Cooper

Dr. Joseph "Doc" Frail

Karl Swenson

Karl Swenson

Tom Flaunce

Karl Malden

Karl Malden

Frenchy Plante

Maria Schell

Maria Schell

Elizabeth Mahler

Reviews

Wuchak

10/10/2024

7/10

**_Ahead-of-its-time Western with Gary Cooper, set in the Great Northwest_** In 1873, an embittered doctor (Cooper) sets up practice in a small gold mining town along The Montana Trail. After acquiring a dubious bondservant (Ben Piazza), he tries to help a wounded Swiss immigrant (Maria Schell). But this stirs up the town’s moral police biddies and the jealousy of a lecherous prospector (Karl Malden), not to mention his successful practice threatens the livelihood of a faith healer (George C. Scott). "The Hanging Tree" (1959) was Cooper’s second to last Western. He passed away due to prostate cancer less than three years after it was shot in the summer of ’58. He was 57 during shooting and carries the film with his towering presence, which doesn’t feel like a 50’s Western, but rather one from the mid-60s. The colorful locations and town set are as good as you’ll see in any Western, very realistic, while angelic Maria Schell is a highlight, the older sister of Maximilian (by four years). Not everything in the story is spelled out. The intelligence of the viewer is respected and thus expected to put the pieces together based on clues offered. It’s good, just kind of ambiguous, which explains its failure at the box office and eventual sleeper status. It no doubt plays better on repeat viewings. This was George C. Scott’s breakout into feature films, but his character isn’t given much screentime and he hams it up a bit too much as the wild-eyed preacher, a one-note loony tune. More dimension was needed in order to ring true. The film runs 1 hour, 47 minutes, and was shot in the general area of Yakima, Washington, including Nile (the mining town) and Goose Prairie (the opening scene). This region is located about a 2.5-hour drive southeast of Seattle. GRADE: B

Similar Movies

There Was a Crooked Man...

6.8

There Was a Crooked Man...

1970

Hell or High Water

7.3

Hell or High Water

2016

Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman: The Heart Within

7.8

Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman: The Heart Within

2001

The Indian Fighter

6.3

The Indian Fighter

1955

The Man from Colorado

6.7

The Man from Colorado

1948

Man Without a Star

6.4

Man Without a Star

1955

The Guns of Fort Petticoat

6.3

The Guns of Fort Petticoat

1957

China 9, Liberty 37

5.3

China 9, Liberty 37

1978

One Dollar Too Many

6.5

One Dollar Too Many

1968

Good Day for a Hanging

6.2

Good Day for a Hanging

1959

Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman: The Movie

8.2

Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman: The Movie

1999

Whirl o' the West

0.0

Whirl o' the West

1921