Souls at Sea

Souls at Sea

3/9/1937 1h 32m 6.0/10

Overview

Michael 'Nuggin' Taylor and Powdah save lives during a sea tragedy in this story about the slave trade on the high seas during 1842.

Director

Henry Hathaway

Top Billed Cast

Gary Cooper

Gary Cooper

Michael 'Nuggin' Taylor

George Raft

George Raft

Powdah

Harry Carey

Harry Carey

Captain of the William Brown

Henry Wilcoxon

Henry Wilcoxon

Lieutenant Stanley Tarryton

Frances Dee

Frances Dee

Margaret Tarryton

Olympe Bradna

Olympe Bradna

Babsie

Reviews

CinemaSerf

CinemaSerf

1/12/2025

7/10

I never really found Gary Cooper to be the most invigorating of actors, but he delivers well here in this tale of maritime treachery. We start at a trial where he ("Nuggin") is being indicted for the killing of survivors from a seaborne disaster in the mid 1800s. It's while the evidence is being given that we are taken back on a retrospective of just how this honourable seaman found himself caught up, with his friend "Powdah" (George Raft) in the evil machinations of "Tarryton" (Henry Wilcoxon). When the boat he was travelling on manages to hit an iceberg, he is left to take charge. As usual there aren't enough spaces on the life boats so panic ensues, and a fairly "survival of the fittest" one at that, the results of which result in his current predicament. How to prove his innocence? Well that might lie in the hands of "Woodley" (George Zucco) who is working for the British Government on a mission to finally eradicate slavery, and who knows a thing or two about the real character of "Nuggin". It's a tautly directed adventure for the first half with plenty of duplicity going on, but when his relationship with "Margaret" (Frances Dee) starts to take a more prominent role in the story, we head into a rather disappointing form of 1930s soapdom. Raft tries his best and in many ways reminded me of Robert Newton but his loyal and decent character is sadly underused whilst the more interesting and perilous anti-slavery storyline becomes a little too subsumed amidst the lace and umbrellas. It's still a film that's well paced for the most part and one that makes you realise that the abolition of slavery in itself didn't actually halt this odious practice in the United States. There were still plenty of officials complicit in this lucrative activity.

Similar Movies

Raiders of the Lost Ark

7.9

Raiders of the Lost Ark

1981

Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull

6.0

Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull

2008

The Colossus of Rhodes

5.9

The Colossus of Rhodes

1961

Captain Calamity

2.5

Captain Calamity

1936

Hong Kong Hot Harbor

6.5

Hong Kong Hot Harbor

1962

The Whip vs. Satan

4.4

The Whip vs. Satan

1979

The Silver Whip

6.3

The Silver Whip

1953

In Which We Serve

6.8

In Which We Serve

1942

King of the Rocket Men

5.2

King of the Rocket Men

1949

Why Girls Love Sailors

5.6

Why Girls Love Sailors

1927

Will o' the Wisp

0.0

Will o' the Wisp

1973